Gary Neville has sparked debate among Premier League fans after claiming one Chelsea midfielder is operating above one of Arsenal’s biggest stars.
The title race took a dramatic twist on matchday seven as Liverpool slipped to their second straight league defeat, allowing Arsenal to climb to the top of the table going into the international break.
Mikel Arteta’s side comfortably dispatched West Ham at the Emirates, but it was Chelsea’s win over Liverpool that generated the biggest headlines — particularly one standout performance in midfield.
Neville Ranks Moises Caicedo Above Declan Rice
Chelsea’s big-money midfielder Moises Caicedo produced one of his best displays in blue, netting a stunning opener before 18-year-old Estevao sealed the win at Stamford Bridge late in stoppage time.
Arsenal were previously keen to sign Caicedo before they turned their attention to Declan Rice, and while Rice has become an instant hit in North London, Gary Neville believes Caicedo has now surpassed him.
Speaking on The Gary Neville Podcast, the former Manchester United captain made his stance crystal clear.
“I’m thinking about players like Declan Rice and others around the league,” Neville said. “But right now, I’m comfortable calling Caicedo the best midfielder in the Premier League.”
He went on to compare the Ecuadorian to other midfield performers:
“Gravenberch last season, maybe Rice, the Newcastle lads, even Rodri over the years — but as of October 2025, Caicedo is playing ahead of them all.”
It’s a bold take, and one that will divide fanbases for sure. But after Chelsea’s statement win, neither Caicedo nor Rice will be concerned with outside noise.
Also read: Arteta Issues Concerning Personal Update on Ødegaard After West Ham Win
Rice Dominates Former Club as Arsenal Take Charge
While Caicedo stole the show in West London, Declan Rice delivered a captain’s performance against his former team, reminding West Ham exactly what they’re missing.
Rice was instrumental in Arsenal’s victory, grabbing yet another goal contribution and dictating play from deep.
Declan Rice vs West Ham:
81 touches 1 goal 92% pass accuracy 100% dribble success 3 key passes 2 shots 2 duels won 2 clearances
Via Sofascore
From driving runs to composed finishing, Rice showed the full range of his abilities — and proved why Arsenal made him their marquee signing.
Summary
Whether you side with Neville’s praise for Caicedo or believe Rice remains ahead, there’s no denying both midfielders are setting the standard in the Premier League right now.
One dominated Liverpool, the other dismantled West Ham and if this continues, the battle between Chelsea’s engine and Arsenal’s powerhouse could become one of the defining storylines of the title race.
